
Yes I know it sounds crazy but I think that it is a very real possibility. The Indians will probably go after just one of the those two; however, I believe they can get both.
Sure it sounds like I am talking crazy but I am really not. The Indians as an organization has exactly what the Rockies need, pitching pitching pitching. This goes through every single level of the organization. Plus we have many other fairly good prospects to go along with the pitching.
The Rockies are not going to win this year nor next year, so why keep Holliday. I am sure that we all know that Holliday will walk after the 2009 season for a bigger contract, way of the game. So, you have to look at it this way. The Rockies are going to lose Holliday either way so why not trade him and get some good possibly great prospects. That will come fairly inexpensive.
Atkins is the same boat basically, except they have a highly-touted thirdbaseman, Ian Stewart, still waiting in the wings to take over, trading Atkins would allow Ian Stewart to take over, and make the move to the young players that the Rockies want to accomplish.
Here are the Players for the Indians I would include in the deal.
- Jeremy Sowers- He had a little bit of a rough start last season but it looks like he is back, he pitched well in the two games he pitched in the majors, only 3 Earned runs in both starts. One against the Yanks (with A-rod and Posada) and against Cinci when they were getting hot. He also has a 2.08 in AAA with 60.2 innings pitched.
- Adam Miller- The Indians number one pitching prospect, 1.88 era in just under 30 IP.
- Brad Snyder- What looks like the most polished OF prospect down in AAA.
- Shin Soo-Choo- Yes he is 27, but he can hit. He looks good and he still has a young everything. The Indians will have a hard time parting with him but it has to be done.
- Ryan Garko- Sure the Rockies still have Helton, but he is getting older and Garko is a very solid firstbaseman, he still has the time to blossom into a great hitter.
- Jeff Stevens- another great pitching prospect, a 2.51 era with 3o innings in AA ball
- Randy Newsome- Yet another good pitching prospect, in the Indians Organization. He has a 1.09 era in 25 innings pitched in Class-AA.
- A player to be named later.
Sure it looks like the Indians are giving up a lot to get Holliday and Atkins, but the tribe really needs some Offense. Even while losing all that pitching the Indians have some very good, pitching prospects down in Class-A and AA. This would be great for both teams, Rockies will get some Good to Great Pitching Prospects (something they have always wanted) and some everyday players.
Now if this deal gets made lets look at the Indians Batting Lineup.
- Grady Sizemore- just a great player all the way around.
- Ben Francisco- will be playing RF and get hit with the best of them.
- Hafner- I am sure once he gets his shoulder fixed he will be back.
- Martinez- Still a great player, still can hit, still has at least 5 good years left.
- Holliday- A superstar enough said.

- Peralta- a good hitting Shortstop
- Atkins- this will cut down At bats but I am sure with this lineup he will still get a lot of ABs and RBIs
- Beau Mills- Firstbaseman with great power, tearing up Kinston right now. (picture at the right)
- Asdrubal Cabrera- the best place for him.
- Casey Blake might be gone but if not he will become a Utility player and good one at that.
- Franklin Gutierez- the 4th outfielder with great defense and speed.
- Jamey Carroll- Probably gone but still would be a serviceable MI who does all the small things.
- Michael Aubrey- a backup firstbaseman who will be great as a backup
- Shopach- Still need a backup catcher, and his defense is good if it isn't him then it will be Alex Castillo
The Starting rotation
- Fausto Carmona- in contract for many years to come, will be the ace.
- C.C. Sabthia- if he isn't gone (I don't think he will be)
- Aaron Laffey- this guy is special
- Cliff Lee- he won't repeat this year's numbers but he will still be more than solid
- Jake Westbrook- worked on his breaking ball and changeup, both are strikeout pitches and he looks better than ever.
The bullpen
- Jensen Lewis- 6th and long term
- Rafael Betancourt- 7th possibly eight inning depending on if he rebounds.
- Rafael Perez- 8th inning (set up guy)
- Masahide Kobayashi- closer, Blowrowski will be gone.
That bullpen if they all return to form will be able to shorten any game, plus you want your better relief pitchers out their, the sooner to get to your closer.
I think that the deal would be great for both teams. In my opinion atleast.
Tell me what you think thank you.